New Political Landscape

Well, we’ve woken to a new political landscape and no mistake. The SNP are to be congratulated on their victory which is decisive and very clear.

There have been shocks and surprises all over the place and I think that even the SNP activists that I know, who were expecting a good night are themselves surprised by the extent of it.  All kinds of good people who have been in the parliament will no longer be there and I’d guess some who were not really expecting to be elected have been. It’s a brutal process, not least for those who work alongside politicians – some of whom who will have been hoping for a job to continue only to wake up this morning to find that they are out on their ear too.

There will be changes too. Labour has had a bad night in Scotland. Red Clydeside ain’t red nae mair, nae mair and there will be much weeping over some of those losses. It was clear in recent weeks that it was not going Labour’s way. They’ve lost a lot and lost it quickly. At the start of the year, I was predicting that Labour would be back into power. Now it seems astonishing that anyone could have thought they would do well.

It was a terrible result for the Liberal Democrats. As bad as I thought it might be. (And I did correctly predict that in January).

Nick Clegg’s line is that the voters have judged the Lib Dems because they have seen them delivering Tory cuts. It’s not true though. Voters have judged the Lib Dems because they feel betrayed by them and by him in particular.

It’s not cuts, Nick. It’s tuition fees.

There will be no climbing back, no comeback, no return to anything without that being recognised. And to recognise it is to recognise that there needs to be some changes. The problem is not the Tories and it isn’t Labour’s legacy.

It has all gone wrong because of two images – the first the picture that people have in their minds of all those candidates signing pledges on tuition fees which came to nothing. The second is the sight of a Westminster-educated lad so thrilled that he was allowed to play with the Bullingdon boys that he did his best to blend in and started to look like them.

The Lib Dems need a new leader and need one soon. (And I’m not talking about Tim Farron either). The coalition needs to be run on completely different lines. Business, not pleasure. No more joint press conferences in the Rose Garden. No more attacking Labour as though doing so is the very business of government – it isn’t.

And a swift and clear statement that on tuition fees, the party and particularly its leader, got it wrong.

On the election tomorrow

We’ve a Scottish parliamentary election tomorrow. My good wishes to all candidates – I know what it feels like to be a parliamentary candidate. You enter into this strange other worldliness where nothing else matters.  The focus narrows and all you know about is the task in hand and the team that are hopefully working their socks off around you. It is intense, it’s physical, you meet more people than you can remember and you have to speak coherently in public at odd times of day. Its all a bit like putting on Holy Week.

I was a Liberal Democrat candidate in 2005 in a Westminster election and it was one of the best experiences of my life. I learned a lot and was surrounded by great people who, bemused as I think they were by my day job, taught me more about mission and outreach than anyone ever did during my priestly formation.

I don’t campaign any more – when I came to Glasgow I realised that this job was a choice which ruled that out, at least for a time. I needed to concentrate on the task at hand and that was a good choice though I know that it did disappoint some folk and I can’t say it wasn’t made without sometimes wondering what might have been had I taken another path. It was widely known when I came here in the congregation what I’d been up to, so I’ve never felt as coy about talking about my own politics as some clergy do.

Not surprisingly, I feel for Liberal Democrat candidates this time around. People will have been working intensely hard, campaigning for years for a seat which a year ago might have seemed almost with their grasp, only for everything to fall apart as national disappointments about the current national Conservative – Lib Dem coalition have reached fever pitch. People feel betrayed by the Liberal Democrats over the tuition fees debacle and tomorrow is very likely to be payback time.

The last year has shown that the Liberal Democrats were barely ready for government. We might have guessed that by the run of silly gay sex scandals of a while ago in the Westminster parliamentary party and the lack of any really well developed economic policy. The disappointment is terrible, particularly for those who were looking for (and were promised) something different and have found politics to be business as usual but with an added dose of ideological right-wing cuts being rolled out in the name of conquering the all too real economic challenge.

“So,” people say to me, “how will you vote now?”

Well, I’m as disappointed as anyone else in the year that is past. So, I’ve made it my business to read the manifestos of the parties and made my decision based on them.  (If you want a quick shortcut, the Scottish Vote Compass will give you a quick quiz and then tell you which party you are nearest to).

So, who am I supporting now?

Having looked at everything that is on offer, I’ll be supporting the Liberal Democrats. It’s not a vote in support of the Coalition – I’m no more supportive of that than I was on day one. Its because I’m still a liberal at heart and policywise, that’s the party that I’m closest to. I didn’t become a Lib Dem because of Nick Clegg nor any personality. I didn’t become a Lib Dem because of success – indeed the idea of Lib Dems in government when I joined was, well, pretty unthinkable. I became a Liberal Democrat because of policy. Indeed, when I did apply to be a candidate, it was policy which carried me though – that and a humdinger of a mock speech, which I’ve still got knocking around somewhere.

So its clear where my vote goes – it goes with what I believe in not with the failures of individuals. And there are going to need to be people around to carry the liberal vision when this current Orange-Book liberalism which is in the ascendency at the moment, collapses in the face of its own contradictions.

Well, it’s clear where it goes on the Regional List ballot paper tomorrow.

The constituency vote is another game altogether.